Hotels in Cape Cod and the Islands

Based on the ratings from momondo users, the top-rated hotel in Cape Cod and the Islands is Vineyard Harbor Motel, located in Vineyard Haven and with an average rating of 9,8. The second highest-rated hotel in Cape Cod and the Islands is Chatham Bars Inn, which is found in Chatham and was given an average score of 9,1 by our users. The third best hotel rating is a 9,1, which was given to White Elephant Hotel in Nantucket.

The most popular hotel in Cape Cod and the Islands is Margaritaville Resort Cape Cod, which has a rating of 8,0 out of 10 from 1 230 of our users. In the past 12 months, 6% of all our users who booked hotels in Cape Cod and the Islands chose to stay at Margaritaville Resort Cape Cod.

For a double room in Cape Cod and the Islands during the month of December, you can expect rates to be around R5 751 per night on average. The cheapest double room in Cape Cod and the Islands in December was R602 per night in the city of Falmouth.

Our users typically find that West Yarmouth has the lowest per night rates in the country at just R1 480. West Yarmouth offers hotels rooms at an average rate that is 66% lower than the average city in Cape Cod and the Islands.

Jared Coffin House (R3 878 per night) is the most popular hotel in Cape Cod and the Islands for families, according to our data. You could also look into booking a room at either Margaritaville Resort Cape Cod (R2 443 per night) or Sea Crest Beach Resort (R2 388 per night) as both hotels are also great for families.

Although room rates may vary depending on the time of year, these top three couples hotels in Cape Cod and the Islands have the following average rates: R3 878 per night at Jared Coffin House, R10 044 per night at White Elephant Hotel and R3 268 per night at Nantucket Inn.

As of December 2025, there are 7 899 operators available to choose from for hotels in Cape Cod and the Islands.

Prices for hotels in Cape Cod and the Islands refresh daily.